Sports: Reimagined - What If Carlos Beltran Didn't Strike Out In Game 7 Of The 2006 NLCS?

If there was one play I could change in my life, it would be this right here. If the Mets somehow came back to win that game 7 at Shea, I have full confidence they go on to dominate the Tigers the same way the Cardinals did. If you remember correctly the Tigers threw the ball all over the field, much like the 2015 Mets blew it with their defense, and the Cardinals ended up ROLLING. No way that we could ever know if the same play would have held true had they been facing the Mets, but what I do know is the Mets were a WAGON. Their pitching was banged up with injuries (If Pedro and El Duque were healthy I think they would have cruised to a World Series), but the makeshift rotation featuring the Human Rain Delay Steve Trachsel and Oliver PER-ez was doing just enough for that bombsquad lineup to carry them through Detroit. Reyes Lo Doca Beltran Delgado Wright Floyd Shawn Green Jose Valentin and Endy "The Catch" Chavez...what a phenomenal lineup. The first 2/3 of that batting order is about as good as it gets, and even the back third with the Stache Jose Valentin and The Chosen One Shawn Green was made up of solid gritty veterans.

Goddam, man. I loved that team so, so much. I was 21 at the time. I watched every. single. game. that year. 2006 and 2007 were the years I was most dedicated to Mets baseball in my life, and both ended in equal-but-different heart breaking agony. If I were to do a Sports: Reimagined for 2007, it would have to be a 20 minute long video as I would have to reimagine the entire month of September. Blowing 7 games with 17 to play doesnt come down to one single pitch like 2006 did. But that one at bat with Carlos could have altered my life forever.

Important to remember a few things - the Mets were down 2. The only reasonable ask of Carlos in that situation was to hopefully tie it with a base knock. Its not like we had the winning run 90 feet away. And Lord knows the only way our boy Paulie Lo Duca was scoring on that at bat is if the ball went over the fence. (I'll never forget one time when the bases were loaded, I dont think it was this at bat, and Howie Rose was on the call....he goes "The Mets have wheels on the bases. Chavez at third, great speed. Reyes at second, great speed, Lo Duca at first, great guy!" One of my favorite play by play jokes ever.) Love ya Paulie, but it would have taken an act of God to have you score from first like Griffey in the 95 ALDS. SO, the point is, on top of the fact that Carlos Beltran was the best free agent signing the Mets ever made, on top of the fact that 2006 was the best season any Met had ever had up until that point, on top of the fact that he was the best center fielder in baseball, on top of the fact that the Mets wouldnt have even made it to game 7 if it wasnt for his home run in game 1 which he singlehandedly won, and his 2 homers in the game 4 blowout...its also NOT his fault the Mets lost that game. If you want to motherfuck anyone, its Aaron Heilman and Yadier Molina. Do not put your stank on Carlos Beltran. He's still the best player this franchise has ever seen. There's nothing he could have done with that curveball. Wainwright made the pitch of a lifetime when he was a little known rookie, and nobody could have done anything with that pitch.

But man oh man would it have been nice to at least fight that pitch off and get another crack at a fastball. Who knows what would have happened. 

Latest Videos

25 videos

1
Barstool Pizza Review - JT's Pizza & Pub (Grandview Heights, OH)

Barstool Pizza Review - JT's Pizza & Pub (Grandview Heights, OH)

2
Bears Loss Hits Hard & Re-Ranking 2024 QB Class | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

Bears Loss Hits Hard & Re-Ranking 2024 QB Class | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

3
The Writer Cup is BACK | Team Whit vs. Team Riggs

The Writer Cup is BACK | Team Whit vs. Team Riggs

4
Barstool Pizza Review - Artisan Pizza Cafe (Columbus, OH)

Barstool Pizza Review - Artisan Pizza Cafe (Columbus, OH)

5
How Much Of My Lesson On World War 2 With Francis Do I Remember?

How Much Of My Lesson On World War 2 With Francis Do I Remember?

6
Jon Gruden & Greg Olsen Break Down NFL Week 1, Dave on Michigan | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

Jon Gruden & Greg Olsen Break Down NFL Week 1, Dave on Michigan | Wake Up Barstool Full Ep...

7
IT'S FOOTBALL SEASON BABY | Pro Football Football Show Week 1

IT'S FOOTBALL SEASON BABY | Pro Football Football Show Week 1

8
Dave Portnoy Returns to Barstool Sports Advisors - Week 1

Dave Portnoy Returns to Barstool Sports Advisors - Week 1

9
Barstool Pizza Review - Jeff's Pizza Shop (Ames, IA)

Barstool Pizza Review - Jeff's Pizza Shop (Ames, IA)

10
We Created a New Show With FOX Sports | VIVA TV

We Created a New Show With FOX Sports | VIVA TV

11
Spitgate & NFL Supreme Debate | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

Spitgate & NFL Supreme Debate | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

12
Frank Walks Episode 70: Joe Theismann presented by BODYARMOR

Frank Walks Episode 70: Joe Theismann presented by BODYARMOR

13
Barstool Pizza Review - Harvest Pizzeria (Dublin, OH) presented by DraftKings

Barstool Pizza Review - Harvest Pizzeria (Dublin, OH) presented by DraftKings

14
Tank Cooks Tucker's World Famous Bacon Chub

Tank Cooks Tucker's World Famous Bacon Chub

15
Dave Portnoy Beats Barstool Employee In Poker Match For $20,000 | The Unnamed Show - Episode 70

Dave Portnoy Beats Barstool Employee In Poker Match For $20,000 | The Unnamed Show - Episo...

16
Kenny Dillingham Joins & NFL Is Back | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

Kenny Dillingham Joins & NFL Is Back | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

17
Who Has the Best Name In College Football ROUND 2 (The Bracket, Vol. 188)

Who Has the Best Name In College Football ROUND 2 (The Bracket, Vol. 188)

18
Barstool Pizza Review - Grandad's Pizza & Pub (Columbus, OH)

Barstool Pizza Review - Grandad's Pizza & Pub (Columbus, OH)

19
RICO VS. NADU PICKS CONTEST UNLEASHES CHAOS | PICK EM WEEK 2

RICO VS. NADU PICKS CONTEST UNLEASHES CHAOS | PICK EM WEEK 2

20
Raw Dogging at Pretty Odd Wieners in Tahoe, CA

Raw Dogging at Pretty Odd Wieners in Tahoe, CA

21
Picking Up Guys While Picking My Nose!

Picking Up Guys While Picking My Nose!

22
Week 2 CFB Rankings & NFL QB Debate | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

Week 2 CFB Rankings & NFL QB Debate | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

23
Barstool Pizza Review - Bobby Jo’s Pizza (Columbus, OH)

Barstool Pizza Review - Bobby Jo’s Pizza (Columbus, OH)

24
Dave At Ohio State & Belichick's Debut | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

Dave At Ohio State & Belichick's Debut | Wake Up Barstool Full Episode

25
ELI MANNING SURPRISES THE BARSTOOL OFFICE | VIVA TV

ELI MANNING SURPRISES THE BARSTOOL OFFICE | VIVA TV