NEW: Saratoga x Barstool Collection SHOP NOW

Sports: Reimagined - What If Butler's Gordon Hayward Hit The Half Court Shot To Win The 2010 NCAA Tournament?

The most iconic missed shot in college basketball history. Nay, the most iconic missed shot in all of basketball history. But, what if? What if Gordon Hayward drilled this half court shot in Indianapolis to complete arguably the most surprising run to an NCAA title in Tournament history. 

This is the one non-Kentucky play I'd most want to change. It alters the course of college hoops history! Butler becomes a 'mid-major' (remember they were a Horizon League team) to win a title. There are no doubt movies that come out about this team and that run, especially considering this game and the Final Four took place in Indianapolis - the home town of Butler. 

Think of all the other things too. K has one less title and goes from 2001 until at least 2015 (don't even get me started on that Final Four ironically enough in Indianapolis) with a title. Does Brad Stevens leave a year early? Will more NBA teams be willing to take on college basketball champion Brad Stevens instead of the Celtics waiting a year for back-to-back title game appearance Brad Stevens? That offseason alone the Rockets, Warriors, Lakers, Timberwolves, Raptors and Pistons all changed head coaches. Oh and it wasn't Mike D'Antoni or Steve Kerr taking those jobs. 

Not only that but you had the perfect call too. Jim Nantz, arguably the biggest big game voice out there, calling the free throws from Zoubek. 'Butler has no timeouts. It's Hayward pulling it down, getting around Zoubek. At halfcourtttt. Launches the shotttttttt. OHHHHHHH IT ALMOST WENT IN.' But what if it was. Nantz had that called lined up for years, YEARS. The only thing missing was Bill Raftery on the call since this was the Clark Kellogg era. Well, that and Hayward actually making it.  

I still can't believe he missed it.

Latest Videos

25 videos

1
Flight Controversy Re-Ignites Barstool's Biggest Rivalry | VIVA TV

Flight Controversy Re-Ignites Barstool's Biggest Rivalry | VIVA TV

2
Frank Walks Episode 64: Tiki Barber presented by BODYARMOR

Frank Walks Episode 64: Tiki Barber presented by BODYARMOR

3
Barstool Pizza Review - Ro's Pizza Restaurant (Watertown, CT) presented by Kraken

Barstool Pizza Review - Ro's Pizza Restaurant (Watertown, CT) presented by Kraken

4
Raw Dogging at Mr. Beef in Chicago

Raw Dogging at Mr. Beef in Chicago

5
Which Superhero Would You Want To Defend Earth? (The Bracket, Vol. 181)

Which Superhero Would You Want To Defend Earth? (The Bracket, Vol. 181)

6
Golfing In The Slums Of Mumbai

Golfing In The Slums Of Mumbai

7
Barstool Pizza Review - Anna's Prospect Apizza (Prospect, CT)

Barstool Pizza Review - Anna's Prospect Apizza (Prospect, CT)

8
Shane Victorino, Open Championship Preview W/ Shane Bacon, Kyle Schwarber Wins The First Ever Swing Off, Mt Rushmore Of Things People Don't Care About

Shane Victorino, Open Championship Preview W/ Shane Bacon, Kyle Schwarber Wins The First E...

9
Dave Portnoy Reviews The Viral $25 Dubai Chocolate Bars With The Snack Boys

Dave Portnoy Reviews The Viral $25 Dubai Chocolate Bars With The Snack Boys

10
Fighting In Public Prank Pt. 2 (ft. Tommy Smokes)

Fighting In Public Prank Pt. 2 (ft. Tommy Smokes)

11
Tank Cooks Ambrosia Salad

Tank Cooks Ambrosia Salad

12
Barstool Pizza Review - Caloroso Eatery & Bar (Shelton, CT)

Barstool Pizza Review - Caloroso Eatery & Bar (Shelton, CT)

13
Dave Looks for Answers on Jeff Nadu's Flight - Barstool Rundown - July 14th, 2025

Dave Looks for Answers on Jeff Nadu's Flight - Barstool Rundown - July 14th, 2025

14
Barstool Pizza Review - Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs (West Haven, CT)

Barstool Pizza Review - Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs (West Haven, CT)

15
Trevor Lawrence, Mt Rushmore Of Worst Places To Be Violently Hungover, HR Derby Picks And We Get Zac A Date With A Fan

Trevor Lawrence, Mt Rushmore Of Worst Places To Be Violently Hungover, HR Derby Picks And ...

16
Locked In The Office Until Winning a Championship in College Football 26 | VIVA TV

Locked In The Office Until Winning a Championship in College Football 26 | VIVA TV

17
Frank Walks Episode 63: Mike Buckley presented by BODYARMOR

Frank Walks Episode 63: Mike Buckley presented by BODYARMOR

18
Barstool Pizza Review - Jimmy's Apizza (Milford, CT) presented by Rhoback

Barstool Pizza Review - Jimmy's Apizza (Milford, CT) presented by Rhoback

19
Trolli Gummi Pops Somehow Perfectly Blend Ice Pops And Candy Using Black Magic

Trolli Gummi Pops Somehow Perfectly Blend Ice Pops And Candy Using Black Magic

20
Raw Dogging at Famous Eddies Hot Dogs Hot Dogs in NYC

Raw Dogging at Famous Eddies Hot Dogs Hot Dogs in NYC

21
A Hilarious History Lesson On The Invention Of The Telephone

A Hilarious History Lesson On The Invention Of The Telephone

22
What Is The Craziest Firework Name? (The Bracket, Vol. 190)

What Is The Craziest Firework Name? (The Bracket, Vol. 190)

23
India is the Most Chaotic Place I’ve EVER Traveled

India is the Most Chaotic Place I’ve EVER Traveled

24
Barstool Pizza Review - Nicky's Place (East Haven, CT)

Barstool Pizza Review - Nicky's Place (East Haven, CT)

25
Tank Cooks Italian Lemon Ice

Tank Cooks Italian Lemon Ice