Former MLB Commissioner Fay Vincent Says MLB Players Were Working On Owning Equity In Their Franchises Before Union Head Michael Weiner Died Suddenly In 2013

I got 30 minutes with former MLB commish Fay Vincent today on CCK. I wish I had 30 hours. Dude is so goddam smart and obviously coming from a place of experience. While he was very careful to put out the disclaimer that he is no longer directly involved and cant say anything with certainty, there was a few fascinating bytes from this conversation that I think was more interesting than anything I've heard in 3 months of discussion amid Corona Virus:

1) Former MLBPA Executive Director Michael Weiner was focused on getting players equity stakes in their franchises. The growing sentiment around the league was entities like MLB.com, regional networks, and streaming rights were all massive, massive money makers from which players felt they should be seeing profits. Players realized that the Yankees could turn around and sell their team for $8-10 billion and that the players wouldnt see a dime of that money. Despite being paid upper echelon salaries, they were being taxed at the working class level, and that they were interested in obtaining a piece of the pie that would be taxed as a capital gain. Basically, despite being wealthy, players were fed up with being treated like the average working man and wanted to be treated the same way billionaire owners are. And the way this was going to happen was by Michael Weiner getting them a piece of equity in all the ancillary revenue streams. Well, Michael Weiner (Who Vincent described as "brilliant") died suddenly at the age of 51. Tony Clark was unanimously voted as his successor, but Vincent stated he didnt believe Clark was "sophisticated" enough to get that done.

Sounds like for the foreseeable future, the prospects of players getting their piece of the pie died with Michael Weiner

2) He believes owners will have to eventually open their books. Not only because it only makes business sense that they will eventually have to a split with players, but how can you agree to X% of an unknown number?? But also because the Players Union is incredibly strong and has shown a willingness to shut down before and wont hesitate to do it again. I was stunned to hear him say this as casually as he did. I would have thought theres NO WAY IN HELL those owners would ever give you a look behind the curtain, but he seemed to think its the only logical progression. Forget about Corona Virus and salvaging the 2020 season - if owners agree to show their financials, the landscape of baseball is forever changed after that. Give these players, who are the main attraction on the field, full public transparency and leverage, and theres no way they dont finish what Michael Weiner started.

In addition to those bombshells he also discussed how the collusion case from 1990 is mainly responsible for the shitty relationship between players and owners and how he believes theres a reasonably good chance there will not be baseball in 2020. 

Man said more in 5 questions than any sports writer, player, or executive has said in years. Fascinating stuff. 

Latest Videos

25 videos

1
First "Barstool Beach House" Night Out Goes Off The Rails | VIVA TV

First "Barstool Beach House" Night Out Goes Off The Rails | VIVA TV

2
Frank Walks Episode 61: Trevor May presented by BODYARMOR

Frank Walks Episode 61: Trevor May presented by BODYARMOR

3
Barstool Pizza Review - Pizza Di Farfalla (New Lenox, IL)

Barstool Pizza Review - Pizza Di Farfalla (New Lenox, IL)

4
Raw Dogging at Hot Dog Hut in Harrison, NJ

Raw Dogging at Hot Dog Hut in Harrison, NJ

5
Talking Barstool Basketball & More From The Writer Cup | The Unnamed Show Episode 64

Talking Barstool Basketball & More From The Writer Cup | The Unnamed Show Episode 64

6
Who Is The Best Action Movie Hero? (The Bracket, Vol. 179)

Who Is The Best Action Movie Hero? (The Bracket, Vol. 179)

7
Barstool Pizza Review - La Villa Restaurant (Chicago, IL)

Barstool Pizza Review - La Villa Restaurant (Chicago, IL)

8
Tank Cooks Baked Creamy Crispy Chicken

Tank Cooks Baked Creamy Crispy Chicken

9
Barstool Pizza Review - Chicago's Pizza (Chicago, IL) presented by Rhoback

Barstool Pizza Review - Chicago's Pizza (Chicago, IL) presented by Rhoback

10
Tank's Ballpark Tour: Globe Life Park Home of the Texas Rangers

Tank's Ballpark Tour: Globe Life Park Home of the Texas Rangers

11
REVIEW: '28 Years Later' Is the Best Zombie Movie In Ages Despite An All-Time Strange Ending

REVIEW: '28 Years Later' Is the Best Zombie Movie In Ages Despite An All-Time Strange Endi...

12
Dave Puts Asterisks On Thunder Title After Achilles Injury - Barstool Rundown - June 23rd, 2025

Dave Puts Asterisks On Thunder Title After Achilles Injury - Barstool Rundown - June 23rd,...

13
Barstool Pizza Review - Dino's Italian Pizza (Chicago, IL)

Barstool Pizza Review - Dino's Italian Pizza (Chicago, IL)

14
The Dozen Brings Chaos to the Barstool Office | VIVA TV

The Dozen Brings Chaos to the Barstool Office | VIVA TV

15
Frank Walks Episode 60: Rone presented by BODYARMOR

Frank Walks Episode 60: Rone presented by BODYARMOR

16
Barstool Pizza Review - La Pizza Nostra (Miami, FL) presented by Kraken

Barstool Pizza Review - La Pizza Nostra (Miami, FL) presented by Kraken

17
Raw Dogging at McKenna's Pub in NYC

Raw Dogging at McKenna's Pub in NYC

18
Hitting On Lifeguards (Pt. 2)

Hitting On Lifeguards (Pt. 2)

19
The Show Revolts Over The Dozen Schedule | The Unnamed Show Episode 63

The Show Revolts Over The Dozen Schedule | The Unnamed Show Episode 63

20
Barstool Pizza Review - Mamale Cafe (Bay Harbor Islands, FL)

Barstool Pizza Review - Mamale Cafe (Bay Harbor Islands, FL)

21
Tank Cooks Grilled Tomahawk Pork Chops

Tank Cooks Grilled Tomahawk Pork Chops

22
Rold Gold Responds To Dot's With New Doritos Cool Ranch Collab

Rold Gold Responds To Dot's With New Doritos Cool Ranch Collab

23
Barstool Pizza Review - Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza (Miami, FL) presented by Rhoback

Barstool Pizza Review - Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza (Miami, FL) presented by Rhoback

24
Francis Teaches An Idiot The Vietnam War

Francis Teaches An Idiot The Vietnam War

25
Barstool Pizza Review - Marc's Artisanal Pizzeria (Miami Beach, FL)

Barstool Pizza Review - Marc's Artisanal Pizzeria (Miami Beach, FL)